Bacterial Systematics on its Way to Become a Scientific Discipline
Bacterial Systematics on its Way to Become a Scientific Discipline
Erko Stackebrandt
Deutsche Sammlung von Mikroorganismen und Zelkulturen
GmbH, Mascheroder weg 1b, D-38121 Braunschweig, Germany
The ultimate goal of microbial systematics in the eyes
of early microbiologists was to relate microbial taxonomy
to evolution, thus putting microbiology on a level
footing with botany and zoology. Almost as dramatic
as the realisation that gross morphology (rods, cocci,
spirilla) or physiological groups (phototrophs, chemolithotrophs,
anaerobes) did not consistently form coherent evolutionary
units, leading to an abandonment of taxonomy incorporating
evolutionary principles, has been the realisation that
it is, indeed, possible to examine evolutionary relationships
within prokaryotes. Just as previous generations of
microbiologists were reluctant to abandon the search
for the key to evolutionary relationships, so too have
the heirs of the determinative system been reluctant
to change the course of prokaryotic taxonomy towards
the present evolutionary oriented science which it
seems destined to become.
Taxonomic units and ranks, arbitrarily defined by microbiologists
to facilitate communication, are absent in nature.
The construction of a hierarchical system is necessarily
a compromise that takes into account our inability
to fully understand the mode and tempo at which individual
bacterial cells evolve, the restriction to base taxonomic
conclusion on a minority of existing organisms, hence
on a small fraction of biodiversity only, and the subjectiveness
with which taxonomists consider characters to be "important"
or less significant. Eventually it may be possible
to define taxa at all levels exclusively on the basis
of taxon-specific sequence idiosyncrasies alone. From
a taxonomic point of view, the restriction of the wealth
of information contained in and expressed by the genome,
to the mere analysis of the primary structure of macromolecules
would not take advantage of the evolutionary process
at all levels of information.
In order to respond to the modern developments in microbial
taxonomy the concept of a "polyphasic" taxonomy
has been developed. The major emphasis of the polyphasic
system is to establish a framework of phylogenetic
groupings and to subsequently delineate these groupings
based on suitable phenotypic characteristics. Decisions
about the rank of an organism in a hierarchical system
is made on the basis of contributions of geno- and
phenotypic properties, that distinguish it from neighbouring
groups.